Caol Ila 11, 2000 (G&M)

Caol Ila 2000, G&MFor whatever reason Diageo does not put out very many sherry matured Caol Ilas. This is generally a shame as sherry matured Caol Ilas can be very good indeed. See, for example, this 10 yo from 1996 put out by Gordon & Macphail. G&M, not surprisingly, are the source for a good many sherried Caol Ilas. As they are one of the few indie bottlers with their own filling contracts (at least they used to be) this may possibly be because they fill their own sherry casks (as opposed to buying matured butts from Diageo)–this is all speculation, so please confirm or deny below if you know more. The young sherried Caol Ila I am reviewing today is also from Gordon & Macphail and I hope it will be not too far away from the one linked above in quality.

Caol Ila 11, 2000 (61.4%; Gordon & Macphail; first fill sherry butts 309558 + 59; from a purchased sample)

Nose: Sharp, vegetal peat with a mossy, leafy quality. Some rubber below that and then quite a lot of struck matches (sulphur). The smoke gets sharper with more of an acidic edge with each sniff. With more time some savoury notes come to the surface (nitrate-laden ham) along with some orange peel and a little plummy/apricoty sweetness. With a lot of time a fair bit of the sulphur does burn off on the nose and then there’s a very nice meaty sweetness and quite a lot of salt. Water pulls some cereally notes out from under the smoke and the matches and adds some rubber to the meaty sweetness.

Palate: Very much as on the nose though perhaps less acidic and sans the rubber. It’s hot but drinkable at full strength. Sweeter on the second sip at first, with the plum/apricot thing, and then salty, but just a bit too much of the struck matches. Yeah, time/air is not doing much for the palate; let’s add some water. Water makes this less sharp and less salty and pulls out more citrus and apricot and some stony sweetness. With more time though it gets quite sharp again.

Finish: Long. Hard to tell much development through the alcohol and sharp smoke. Gets saltier as it goes and once the smoke subsides there’s some lingering sweetness. Less acrid with water on the finish and the sweetness expands too but the salt comes back.

Comments: There’s a bit too much sulphur in this one. It’s not too much of a drawback on the nose, but it does make it rather raw and one-dimensional on the palate and even with my high sulphur tolerance it’s a bit much for me neat. With water it’s much improved but it’s still pretty raw and it doesn’t leave a good feeling in my mouth. Alas, it’s rather far away indeed from that lovely 10 yo, 1996.

Rating: 79 points. (Low-mid 80s if I were just nosing it.)

2 thoughts on “Caol Ila 11, 2000 (G&M)

  1. When I was at the distillery, the person leading my tasting specifically said that Caol Ila almost never fills their own sherry casks. There was some talk about the spirit not being suited to sherry, but that’s obviously BS. More likely, Diageo doesn’t care about Caol Ila as anything other than as fodder for their blends and doesn’t really give a rip about making the best possible whisky from it.


    • I don’t think it’s fair to say that they don’t value Caol Ila as anything but blend fodder, just because they stick to a bourbon-wood regime. Why does everyone have to have a sherried version, or a peated one, for that matter? But there is a kernel of truth in what you say, in that fifteen years ago, that was indeed how Caol Ila was viewed–there was no OB single malt, other than the occasional Rare Malt. That’s not so odd, given that the refurbished CI plant essentially replaced Port Ellen, which was viewed the same way. And that’s not so odd, either–the popularity of single malts, and particularly peaty ones, was just beginning to explode. Prior to that, there were lots of distilleries that had no widely available OB’s.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.