
Here, finally, is my last restaurant report from my five-week stay in Bombay this spring. It is on my dinner in April at one of the most lauded fine dining restaurants in India: Masque. The restaurant was founded in 2016 by Aditi Dugar and co-owner, Prateek Sadhu who was also the original executive chef. Sadhu left Masque in 2022 and currently heads Naar in Kasauli—a restaurant that has since overtaken Masque in the excitement department in the Indian fine dining scene. Varun Totlani, who had been part of the opening team in 2016, took over the kitchen at Masque in 2022 and has been in charge since. Masque under Sadhu had set the standard for the second generation of modern Indian fine dining—the first generation being restaurants like Indian Accent in Delhi—and its reputation has not dipped with the transition to Chef Totlani. And so I had hoped to eat at Masque with the missus when we were in Bombay for five weeks in early 2024. But it did not come to pass. Apart from the fact that it’s a very expensive restaurant, it’s a tasting menu-only situation and neither of those things was going to work for us as we had our kids along. This time I was going to be in Bombay by myself and so one of the first things I did before leaving Minnesota was to email the restaurant to see if they had any seats available on the evenings I would be free. I had expected this to be a complicated negotiation but it turned out I had my pick of dates. And so I arrived for dinner on Friday, April 10 for the first seating at 7 pm. Here’s how it went.
I took a cab over from my flat in Worli. There was some road construction in progress on the approach to the restaurant and so drop-offs were happening a little further away. The restaurant had reached out ahead of time to offer to send out a staff member to guide me to the restaurant on arrival. I had demurred and did not regret doing so: it was a short walk and it was very easy to get to the restaurant. But I guess this kind of bespoke hand-holding (some might say infantilizing) is what makes them a Relais & Chateaux restaurant. I was there a bit early and was the first diner let into the restaurant. The space is large, with tables spaced well, and more than a little dark. Most of the seating is on the ground floor. There seems to be a small upstairs section as well—I’m not sure if that’s part of the regular seating or for special meals/groups.
I took my seat at my table and prepared to look at the drinks menu. But there was some confusion before that point. Two days prior to the reservation I had received an email asking if I am vegetarian or non-vegetarian and about dietary restrictions. I’d responded immediately saying that I am omnivorous with no restrictions and had received acknowledgment of that. But at the table a staff member approached me to confirm that I would be eating the vegetarian tasting menu. No, I said, clarifying that I had noted that I am not vegetarian. This was contradicted by the staff member who then got into a long conversation about it with a managerial type. After twiddling my thumbs for a bit, I went over and showed them the email exchange on my phone. It’s possible the confusion may have resulted from my use of the word “omnivorous” rather than “non-vegetarian”. At any rate, after a little more conversation the matter was settled and I sat down to peruse the drinks menu and wait for the non-vegetarian tasting menu to be served.
That drinks menu is large. There are cocktail pairings—and a mezcal flight—to go with the meal and there’s also a long list of house cocktails and spirits. Likewise, there are options for wine pairings, one with international wines and a slightly cheaper one with domestic wines. And there are a bunch of options for wines by the glass and bottle as well. Rather than parse the long list of cocktails, I decided to start with a glass of white wine. I asked the sommelier which of the Indian whites he would recommend with the first half of the meal and he suggested a Viognier from Nashik (from a vineyard apparently owned by Vijay Amritraj!). The wine arrived in short order and then the meal began.
I was eating the summer menu for 2026 and both the card on the table and my server informed me that it comprised 10 courses that were tributes/homages to iconic foods of the city. My write-up below has the names of the courses on it but this was not the experience at the dinner itself. Then it was a menu surprise, which I think is their normal operating procedure. Each dish was described when it was brought to the table and a printed list of courses only provided when the meal was almost over. Here’s how it went.
Course 1: Chaos, Calm, Beauty
I was told later that the title of this course is a departure from Chef Totlani’s preference to mark courses by the names of core ingredients. Well, it was a beautiful presentation. A striking black bowl with chopped raw squid, flowers, coconut etc. arranged attractively in it was presented and a chilled bisque-like soup was poured over it (calm?). This latter turned out to be sea buckthorn broth and was very nicely balanced with sweet and hot notes at first but, alas, became a little soapy as I went. And while the rest also made a very strong impression, a few bites in the squid also began to appear less than optimally fresh, tasting fishier and fishier as it went—I hope this was not the “chaos” part of the name.
Course 2: Four Snacks
“Four Snacks” is not what this course was listed as on the menu; I’m calling it that as that’s what it was: the restaurant’s takes, served together, on four iconic snacks of the city’s various communities. Arbi tuk was presented as a taro puff with drumstick broth inside (sort of like a Sindhi-Hong Kong hybrid) and the Bombay sandwich was presented in a very high concept style: compressed and toasted bread with compressed cucumber, potato and beet and lots of swirls of green, tomato and cheese chutneys. These were cleverly conceived and executed well but I’m afraid this is the kind of modern cheffy flourish that you might appreciate in theory but which will likely make you long for the unfashionable originals. This was also true of the mini-cheese podi dosa, which was very cute to look at but utterly meh on the palate. The fourth snack, on the other hand, was a total let-down. I’ve had very good mod takes on panipuri elsewhere but this white chocolate shell with passion fruit “water” inside really did not do it for me (and made me think wistfully of the fantastic passion fruit-driven panipuri at Copra in San Francisco).
Course 3: Charred Corn | Bhutta Jus | Masa Mathri
So, that was a start that included one course that made a great initial impression and then declined, followed by a course that was meh across the board. I was very glad then that the third course was just outstanding. A bowl filled with warm corn custard, Himalayan trout roe etc. was presented and then a corn jus with chives (apparently cooked over 48 hours) was spooned over. This was served with a masa mathri on the side, “chips and dip” apparently being the idea. Well, I did not eat it a la chips and dip but I could have eaten a bucket of that warm corn custard and broth.
Course 4: Crab Tandoori | Butter Garlic Momo
I regret to inform that with the fourth course we were back to cleverness for its own sake. This course, I was told, is a homage to Trishna, one of the city’s vaunted seafood restaurants (though I will note that none of my food-obsessed Bombay friends ever recommends it to me). Trishna—like many of the cities other seafood restaurants that don’t get recommended to foreigners—is known for their crab preparations in particular and this course pays tribute to two of them. First up is what looks like a crab claw but is really a shaped tart shell with tandoori crab inside. Looked lovely, tasted fine, I guess. The other part of the duo was a momo with crab butter garlic inside. Now, I love good momos and I love good crab butter garlic, and while this was a proper momo with proper crab butter garlic inside, I cannot tell you that it made me wonder where this combination had been all my life. Clever concept but to what end?
At this point I got a second glass of wine, a cabernet sauvignon from Vallonne Vineyards, also in Nashik.
Course 5: Duck Kebab Sausage | Roomali | Fresh Herbs
And this course was a tribute, I was told, to the kabab-slingers of Mohammed Ali Road. The role of seekh kabab was played by a duck sausage which was placed in a mini-roomali roti with pickled veg and herbs and served as a taco. Maybe if I had not been told that this was their take on seekh kababs and roomali rotis I might have liked it more. As it was, I kept wishing it was a proper seekh kabab instead.
Course 6: Lobster | Goan Choriz | Seaweed
Things improved dramatically with this course which saw a smoky bisque poured over a bowl containing lobster, Goan choriz, cordyceps mushroom etc.. By the time I got to the end of it I did feel like the choriz was maybe one ingredient too many but I did like it very much.
Course 7: Bun Maska | Smoked Chicken Chai
I am very happy to say that the next course was not a letdown. Presented as a tribute to bun maska with chai, this featured a lovely bun that was smeared with jaggery and Sindhi spices and togarashi pepper, excellent house-made butter, and a cup of a lovely warming chicken broth (in the role of “chai”).
Course 8: Koji Dosa | Asparagus & Squash Avial | Mutton Gassi
This was the last and largest of the savoury courses and it kept thing generally on the positive track. It was also the most/only traditional presentation of the night. Most of it was served as a thali. On it were a mutton gassi that was rather excellent, featuring lamb neck cooked sous vide. Even better was the asparagus and squash avial. What was missing were appams or neer dosas to mop up those lovely sauces with. Instead, served alongside was a koji dosa. This was tasty enough but not fit to the purpose. Also on the thali were a little cube of lamb brain “chutney” to smear on the dosa, Bhavnagari chillies with chunda and house-made sunchoke chips. All of these were very tasty, especially the brain chutney.
Everything in this course was tasty but I would probably pull the koji dosa and brain chutney out to its own course and serve the avial and gassi with a more suitable starchy accompaniment.
Course 9: Mulberry Kala Khatta
This was the pre-dessert/palate cleanser and featured an awkward trip to the kitchen to see it being made (while kitchen staff stood around uncomfortably) and, for some reason, to have a polaroid portrait of each diner taken. I could have done without all of this theater. The kala khatta itself was very good.
Course 10: Jalebi
As I returned to my table I was finally given the printed menu for the night. I noted that the final course was titled “Jalebi”. I was not expecting a traditional jalebi and did not receive one. Instead what showed up was ice cream with jalebi bits in it, served spiraled out like a jalebi. It was fine.
Mukhwas
Before I could even get into the jalebi all the mukhwas showed up along with tea (Kashmiri kahwa). The mukhwas proper included a fennel meringue and two types of dhana dal goli. Also on the table were three mignardises: mawa cake, walnut fudge and “paan” featuring ajwain leaf, tamarind ganache, and strawberry. All of this was pleasant enough.
For a look at the meal, launch the rather large slideshow below. Scroll down for thoughts on service, to see how much all of this cost and for broader thoughts on the meal. Apologies for the variable quality of the photographs, some of which were taken on my proper camera (though with an all-purpose travel lens) and some with my phone.
Initial static about whether I was going to be eating the vegetarian or non-vegetarian menu aside, service was very good: friendly and professional. The food was described very well and the sommelier was very knowledgeable as well; both his recommendations were spot on. I’ll note here, however, that the restaurant might rethink leading all its re/confirimation emails with language about needing the table back. Perhaps lingering diners have been a problem for the restaurant, and I don’t meant to give the impression that I was very offended, but it’s not exactly hospitality to repeatedly tell a guest before they’ve even arrived about when they have to leave. Once at the time of booking and a gentle reminder upon arrival would seem to be enough. Or maybe just put that a little lower in the emails. It might also not be a bad thing for a restaurant of this ambition (and price point) to find a way to discourage people from taking video calls on their phones (as my neighbours did for most of the meal). Then again, I was an asshole with a camera so maybe I’m not one to talk.
Cost? The total before tip was Rs. 11,899 or just about $128 at the current exchange rate. Of this the tasting menu cost Rs. 8085 or $87. Certainly, this represents very good value compared to similar places in the US and it’s in the same ballpark as places like Indian Accent or even the old-school five star hotel restaurants in major cities. But it is quite expensive in India and for the price I would have liked a better hit rate than I experienced. A few courses and dishes were truly excellent—among the best dishes I ate all year. But too many others were either blah or trying too hard or both. I have more global thoughts on what may be driving the kind of take on modern Indian cuisine that restaurants like Masque present in India (and not just in India) and the formal articulation of Indian food in these contexts. But I’ll reserve those for a separate post on the dynamics of the new wave of high-end Indian restaurants and what I think is the malign influence of the 50 Best Restaurants list and things of that nature. I’ll try to put that up next month.
Alright, this is finally the last of my formal Bombay restaurant reports. I might put up another post at some point featuring some other very special meals that were eaten outside restaurant settings but the restaurant reports are done. Also almost done are my reports from Seoul, which is where I went and met up with the family after Bombay. There are three high-end meals to be written up still from that part of the trip. All of those are from restaurants that have Michelin stars and are broadly in the genre that Masque is in. I’ll try to get all three of those up in December as well and also finish up with my reports from Hokkaido. As for the Twin Cities, I’ll have a report this Wednesday but at the time of this writing, we don’t yet have fixed plans and so I cannot tell you where it will be from. Odds are good that it will be either a Chinese or Thai restaurant. Let’s see how it goes.